To Spank or Not To Spank...that is the question.
Yesterday I went to the Galleria, a very huge shopping mall near where I live. As I was walking around, I heard a child throwing a tantrum because his mom said he couldnt have whatever it was he wanted.
I looked at the mom....a very frazzled looking young lady pushing a pram with a tiny baby...trying to control a very vocal and bad tempered little 4 or 5 year old boy.
I felt sorry for her because the little boy would not listen to her and even so much as purposely disobeyed her when she told him not to touch anything. They were just inside a shop that had breakable stuff that the child could have picked up and dropped and she would have been up for the cost of the item.
Finally with exasperation, she grabbed him by his little wrist and hauled him out of the shop and he screamed!! I thought he might be screaming out of fear of being spanked but he was actually screaming in sheer anger at being hauled out of the shop.
The poor mom tried very hard to calm him down but she was starting to lose it too. Her baby started crying, the child wriggled out of her grip and took off. She tried to call him back but he wouldnt listen. She pretty much ran after him pushing the pram in front of her and caught up very quickly. Then she did what everyone who was witnessing the whole thing happen pretty much knew would happen. She grabbed his arm and whacked his bum!!!
She only whacked him once, and it's as if she suddenly realized..oops, maybe I shouldnt have done that...so many people are watching.
The child started crying but did not try to free himself from her grip this time. He allowed her to lead him away while a few of the bystanders were tut-tut-tutting....I dont know if it was at her for spanking the child...or at the child for being a right proper little so-and-so.
What's the verdict on this, is it okay for a parent to spank a child under these circumstances or not?
User Comments
oh dear...lol....it's a pity that you cant express your opinion without fear of getting into trouble. |
of course, that goes without saying. There's a huge difference between discipline and child abuse. A whack on the bottom for being naughty is one thing...beating the crap out of a child is another. |
I know exactly what you mean about your mother. I, too, have suffered at the hands of a woman who couldn't control her own emotions. |
My daughter lost her children because social services got pulled into their lives. It's a tragedy that affects the children as well as the parents-no matter the cause of their involvement. |
Whenever this subject comes up I remember many years ago on a cold day in NYC when a mother yelled at her kid, "If you didn'i have so many clothes on I would spank you!" |
I feel sorry for flustered Moms in that situation, but I also feel sorry for little kids dragged around a mall and expected to behave like adults. My solution - don't take them shopping. |
I agree with that...lol....time-outs dont worry all the time....my girlfriend's kids think nothing of it so it doesnt work with them...lol. A stinging whack on the butt does though. |
YES! the little booger deserved a good spanking....and will benefit from it in the long run. I agree with okie. |
Creaming....lol...think I will leave it. I have been up all night writing content so I have an excuse for poor grammar and spelling! |
you sound very tired....lol. I dont believe in beating a child in public..verbally or physically. But a quick smack on the bottom for unacceptable behaviour is okay. |



Email
Print Article
Favorites
Report Abuse





Oh, these loaded questions bloggers ask.